Battle of Tukayyid Statistics

Actually quite interesting in that it basically confirms everything we thought mech and result wise - basically the only thing that mattered was the last 2-3 hours and if you stacked the queue with proper 12 mans you won the event as you got queue priority. Damage and kills were almost equal.

Amusingly they "forgot" to give the most important piece of information: how many IS vs how many Clan finished the challenge.

Total matches: 334,558
Matches on each game mode:

• Invasion: 160416
• CounterAttack: 174142

Matches on each map:

• Frost: 71222
• Badlands: 66285
• Gorge: 66114
• Crystals: 65788
• Mountain: 65149

Total players: 17,226

• Total IS Players: 10346
• Total Clan Players: 7312

Players changed from IS to Clan during the event: 380
Players changed from Clan to IS during the event: 52

Players by faction:

• Davion: 2019
• Kurita: 2092
• Liao: 685
• Marik: 1221
• Rasalhague: 1812
• Steiner: 2661
• Clan Smoke Jaguar: 1110
• Clan Jade Falcon: 1516
• Clan Wolf: 2956
• Clan Ghost Bear: 1862

Total Units participated: 2215
Units by Faction:

• Davion: 279
• Kurita: 244
• Liao: 88
• Marik: 149
• Rasalhague: 249
• Steiner: 333
• Clan Smoke Jaguar:146
• Clan Jade Falcon: 207
• Clan Wolf: 357
• Clan Ghost Bear: 265

Units changed from IS to Clan during the event: 56
Units changed from Clan to IS during the event: 12
Units changed within IS factions during the event: 17
Units changed within Clan factions during the event: 17

Total Mechs destroyed: 961,974
Total Clan Mechs destroyed: 481,187
Total IS Mechs destroyed: 480,787

Total Damage Done: 358,768,582
Total Damage Done by IS Mechs: 179,654,088
Total Damage Done by Clan Mechs: 179,114,494

Total Friendly Fire done: 8,345,945
Total Friendly Fire done by IS Mechs: 4,065,350
Total Friendly Fire done by Clan Mechs:4,280,595

Total XP earned: 1,131,894,564
Total CB earned: 110,126,767,605


Top 20 IS Mechs used:

• TDR5SS: 50910
• STK4N: 32887
• TDR9S: 20586
• TDR9SE: 19279
• RVN3L(C): 18858
• TDR9SE(C): 17692
• RVN3L: 16504
• JM6DD: 14933
• DRG1N: 14021
• SDR5D: 13316
• CDA3M: 12475
• FS9S: 10762
• JM6S: 9709
• STKHERO: 9617
• AS7DDC: 9404
• FS9A: 9303
• GRF2N9: 227
• WVR6K: 8532
• RVNHERO: 8510
• RVN2X: 7136

Top 20 Clan mechs used:

• SCRC: 49653
• SCRPRIME: 43981
• TBRC: 43090
• SCRD: 37446
• HBRPRIME: 35288
• MDDPRIME: 27645
• HBRA: 26308
• HBRPRIME(I): 25911
• TBRS: 25320
• TBRPRIME(I): 24229
• HBRB: 22889
• SCRPRIME(I): 21499
• TBRPRIME: 20576
• KFXC: 16455
• MDDA: 13191
• IFRPRIME: 12392
• KFXS: 10989
• MLXPRIME: 10932
• ADRPRIME: 10348
• MDDB: 10206

IS Mechs by Mech Class:

• Light: 134890
• Medium: 144825
• Heavy: 240195
• Assault: 149310

Clan Mechs by Mech Class:

• Light: 114478
• Medium: 205358
• Heavy: 304425
• Assault: 44751

IS Mechs By Chassis

• Thunderbolt: 119429
• Stalker: 54313
• Raven: 53285
• JagerMech: 35017
• Firestarter: 30816
• Hunchback: 30431
• Spider: 19581
• BattleMaster: 18820
• Griffin: 18717
• Centurion: 18706
• Catapult: 18596
• Cataphract: 18005
• Dragon: 17991
• Cicada: 16598
• Atlas: 14765
• Grasshopper: 14071
• Wolverine: 13869
• KingCrab:13690
• Blackjack: 13586
• Banshee: 13581
• Shadowhawk: 13056
• Zeus: 12748
• Quickdraw: 10764
• Locust: 9917
• Enforcer: 9568
• Victor: 9492
• Jenner: 8240
• Awesome: 7666
• Panther: 6902
• Orion: 6322
• Trebuchet: 5368
• Highlander: 4235
• Commando: 3329
• Kintaro: 3027
• Urbanmech: 2820
• Vindicator: 1899

Clan Mechs by Chassis

• Stormcrow: 158911
• TimberWolf: 123730
• Hellbringer: 110396
• MadDog: 59060
• KitFox: 50840
• MistLynx: 34678
• Adder: 28960
• Nova: 25381
• IceFerret: 21066
• DireWolf: 18865
• Warhawk: 17649
• Summoner: 11239
• Gargoyle: 8237

Top 20 IS Mechs being destroyed:

• TDR5SS: 36717
• STK4N: 23558
• TDR9S: 15949
• RVN3L(C): 14863
• TDR9SE: 13670
• TDR9SE(C): 13484
• RVN3L: 12969
• JM6DD: 11465
• DRG1N: 10374
• SDR5D: 10013
• CDA3M: 9341
• JM6S: 7671
• FS9S: 7589
• AS7DDC: 7163
• FS9A: 7099
• STKHERO: 6990
• GRF2N: 6943
• RVNHERO: 6330
• WVR6K: 5843
• JM6FB: 5222

Top 20 Clan Mechs being destroyed:

• SCRC: 38851
• TBRC: 32858
• SCRPRIME: 32589
• HBRPRIME: 28095
• SCRD: 26687
• MDDPRIME: 23225
• HBRPRIME(I): 20330
• HBRA: 20261
• TBRS: 20199
• TBRPRIME(I): 18512
• HBRB: 17309
• TBRPRIME: 16258
• SCRPRIME(I): 15707
• KFXC: 14218
• IFRPRIME: 10734
• MDDA: 10655
• KFXS: 9107
• MLXPRIME: 8754
• MDDB: 8320
• DWFB: 7940

IS being destroyed Mechs by Mech Class:

• Light: 102854
• Medium: 112512
• Heavy: 182823
• Assault: 112456

Clan being destroyed Mechs by Mech Class:

• Light: 89270
• Medium:156883
• Heavy: 239852
• Assault:36113

IS being destroyed Mech by Mech Model:

• Thunderbolt: 88151
• Raven: 40567
• Stalker: 39563
• JagerMech: 27496
• Hunchback: 23898
• Firestarter: 22789
• Spider: 15136
• Catapult: 15033
• Centurion: 15029
• Griffin: 14677
• Cataphract: 14281
• BattleMaster: 14138
• Dragon: 13565
• Cicada: 12476
• Atlas: 11502
• Grasshopper: 10676
• KingCrab: 10556
• Blackjack: 10419
• Banshee: 10362
• Shadowhawk: 10244
• Wolverine: 9960
• Zeus: 9866
• Quickdraw: 8701
• Enforcer: 7618
• Locust: 7483
• Victor: 7319
• Jenner: 6562
• Awesome: 5901
• Panther: 5417
• Orion: 4920
• Trebuchet: 4231
• Highlander: 3249
• Commando: 2691
• Kintaro: 2475
• Urbanmech: 2209
• Vindicator: 1485

Clan being destroyed Mechs by Mech Model:

• Stormcrow: 118748
• TimberWolf: 96061
• Hellbringer: 85995
• MadDog: 48602
• KitFox: 41375
• MistLynx: 26269
• Adder: 21626
• Nova: 20893
• IceFerret: 17242
• DireWolf: 15144
• Warhawk:14252
• Summoner: 9194
• Gargoyle:6717

Total players by challenge points:

PointsPlayers

1: 2021
2: 1166
3: 813
4: 566
5: 1162
6: 713
7: 562
8: 363
9: 345
10: 455
11: 333
12: 299
13: 214
14: 201
15: 373
16: 245
17: 193
18: 139
19: 105
20: 314
21: 195
22: 158
23: 107
24: 105
25: 175
26: 103
27: 76
28: 69
29: 56
30: 170
31: 100
32: 71
33: 43
34: 39
35: 75
36: 61
37: 40
38: 28
39: 39
40: 612
41: 253
42: 137
43: 101
44: 81
45: 116
46: 59
47: 48
48: 45
49: 36
50: 1891


Source: http://mwomercs.com/news/2015/05/1194-battle-tukayyid-statistics

 

PS: 2.33% of all damage done was friendly fire... most amusing statistic.

 

I suck at reading stats, but in the end it seems like the balance work was great, at least seeing the total damage and mechs destoyed so close in numbers, must mean something.

 

Except it also gives away that most IS players achieved far less than the clan pilots:

Total IS Players: 10346
Total Clan Players: 7312

Total Mechs destroyed: 961,974
Total Clan Mechs destroyed: 481,187
Total IS Mechs destroyed: 480,787

Total Damage Done: 358,768,582
Total Damage Done by IS Mechs: 179,654,088
Total Damage Done by Clan Mechs: 179,114,494

Avge IS player: Killed 46.5 Clan mechs and did 17,365 damage
Avge Clan player: Killed 65.75 IS mechs and did 24,496 damage

Not even remotely close.

Coincidentally I think PGI are terrified of admitting how few IS pilots hit 50 completed. The omission of that figure is just too obvious.

 

Coincidentally how low those figures are horrifies me - it gives away how inexperience a lot of the players were or how few matches they attempted. Hard to say which or if both are true as we don't have figures for matches per clan and is player.

 

The number I still want to see the most is how many wins vs losses there were for each side. That, more than anything, will show how balanced/unbalanced the event was in the end.

 

I'm not sure if it works that way, this is why I say I'm confused by stats.

I mean you play 12vs12 (48 vs 48 if you want), so the other IS players where just waiting and those are the stats of actual same number of games, at least I think so. It's not possibile that IS played more then clans, simply because IS are matched vs the clanners.
You can't fight vs no one, so the higher number just means more wait time and naturally less completed events for the IS.

As I see it, the performance is really close, as I test it it's actually the same as well, I get the same scores with clans and IS, actually killing much more with IS and doing more damage vs clans.

The stalker 4N stacking tho, is almost unbeatable, when I've met 12 men for IS with 2 waves of 4N it was just hopeless, solos just have no idea how to face them.

On the other side, when I was on IS, people could more or less deal vs the enemy (of course, since they are always the same 3 mechs) and they didn't suck as bad as clanners vs premades.

For how I see it, and I might be wrong :

-IS better for large and highly organized groups, the low beam duration, STD durability, higher pinpoint and synergy wins in this case.
-Clans better for solo or small groups, brute force wins in this case.

Makes a lot of sense as well.

As a solo player I'm really happy with the balance, I can switch sides and play having fun on both.

 

I run XL's in CW as a skirmisher so that's not entirely relevant for me though. I still am usually the highest damage dealer and killer though.

Which teams take 12 STK-4N's out of interest?

 

I think it was the 228 when I saw it in action.

 

Every time I saw 228, they were using normal mixes of mechs...someone else was talking about a 12 Stalker team at one point, but it's something I've never seen on either side of CW...

 

Like 12x Dual gauss King-Crabs i think its something they only run for fun and testing in a limited number of drops.

 

Back from a surprise weekend to Paris to see Tukayyid overrun by filthy clanners,... can't I really leave you PUGs alone for even an instant?

My take on the numbers,...
Scarily low population, missing wins vs losses, missing IS reaching 40/50

 

Well, have you tried waiting for the match?
OUCH!
Eventually I figure out that unless you have a 12 man for the CW event (viat LFG if needed) then you are waiting for over half an hour as IS to play.

You can play 3 games in regular PUG for that wait time.
Then again that is the problem with CW, too much wait.

I did my 5 games or so for the banner, and that is all.

 

Playing at my usual hours (overnight for US time zones) it was actually pretty fast most of the time thankfully. Rarely saw a queue longer than 8 or 9, and it flowed very quickly. Don't know what I'd have done during the daytime.

 

If you do a full 12 mn from LF then yeah 8-9 minutes can be done. IS is harder since there are less clan players.

 

Heh that was solo, IS side

 

The problem with LFG was that you could only group with your own faction (unless I did something wrong). Even though Steiner was the most represented IS faction, there was never enough people using LFG to put together a 12-man, at least while I was on (~9:00pm to Midnight Pacific time which should still be a fairly high populations).

 

This. IS is the larger population, but has six instead of four. Using LFG as it stood, I was only able to find Laio groups (I'm a dirty merc working on my rep, sue me) during the first half of the event AT ALL, and 10-man was sort of the critical mass, it never hit 12 although I think it may have been such before and after I was actually on for a few drops. After that, having the flag up at all was useless. If even Steiner can't get 12s that way during a peak population period, something's definitely wrong with the system...and it smells suspiciously of faction-specificity, but especially during an event where the only distinction that mattered was Clan vs IS. I understand why that restriction exists as a grouping option, and even the default for regular CW, but during an event where the WHOLE POINT is how the Houses banded together* to kick out the Clans? Ugh. It really is the little things.



*More communication than usual and a common foe, you'd think the mercs would at least have free reign to go in together, right?

 

I actually had a decent time grouping with my own fraction.
Turns out people choosing Marik are generally quite friendly in regards to that.

Too bad there is only a handful of us... at least we are not as bad as the Liaos. Oh well.