BSW-P1 "Mid Range Madness" (6xMRM10, LE300)

Thread in 'BSW-P1' started by Trippton, Jul 20, 2017.

  1. Trippton

    Trippton Active Member

    57
    8
    15


    Weapon Groups:
    1 - 2xMRM10 (left Torso)
    2 - 2xMRM10 (right torso)
    3 - 2xMRM10 (left arm)
    4 - 6xMRM10 (chain-fire)

    I've been averaging between 350-600 damage so far. Good fire support mech, but not as strong solo early on in a match unless you are flanking and unloading into someone's rear armor. Be sure to only fire one 2x group at a time to manage heat or use the chain fire.

    Skills are 32/16/14/0/18/10/1
    Firepower has all 6 of the missile related skills (ammo, spread, high explosive) with some velocity and heat gen.
    Survival is left side for armor to buff the existing quirks.
    Mobility right side for speed tweak.
    Operations for cool run and all but one heat containment.
    Sensors for 3 radar deps down left side.
    Auxiliary for extra consumable.
     
  2. Excalibaard

    Excalibaard 101 010 Staff Member

    4,466
    983
    219
    20 full salvo's is a bit too few for most games imo, especially without backup weapons. With skills it's 24, which is still a bit short of my comfort zone.

    I've downgraded the engine (LE285 or LE280 are both great value-for-tonnage if you're not using the engine heat sink slots) and upped the ammo. Too much ammo could make you too explodey, so I also put in an extra DHS to help with the heatmanagement, though chainfired groups should make it relatively easy to handle. I might even suggest just 2 chainfiregroups like an ERLL boat,

     
  3. Trippton

    Trippton Active Member

    57
    8
    15
    I never had ammo issues due to the heat management problem. Couldn't really do alphas and I usually either chain fired or just fired 2 at a time back to back. Thanks for the alternative build though, I'll give this a go and see how it works when I finally have free time again. :)
     
  4. Excalibaard

    Excalibaard 101 010 Staff Member

    4,466
    983
    219
    If you fire them staggered, you still use the same amount of ammo as when firing them as an alpha, while generating less heat. MRM10s can be fired with up to 4 at a time, so I'd personally just get a group for alpha Torso and alpha Arms, or chainfire both groups and fire them together for 2 pods fired at the same time.
     
    Trippton likes this.
  5. Falconium

    Falconium Administrator Staff Member

    1,499
    470
    67
    Noticed people running builds like this in QP matches, with multiple MRM10s, and I felt the need to point something out. This thread seemed as good a place as any.

    Normally you'd expect that running multiple smaller versions of a weapon type should yield some advantage over running fewer, larger versions. If you look at LRMs, SRMs, Streaks, etc. you will generally always notice some sort of bonus or advantage to running the smaller versions. Usually this involves reduced cooldowns, at the cost of damage/heat efficiency, and/or increased damage/ton efficiency.

    In the case of MRMs, however, that is technically not the case; there is a certain argument to be made for running MRM10s in certain, very specific circumstances; but normally, it doesn't seem worthwhile.

    (All MRMs have the same range and velocity, so I won't address those aspects here.)
    I'll compare 4xMRM10 to 1xMRM40. This amounts to the same damage, at the same range, at the same velocity, for the same weight/tonnage.

    Now here's how they differ:
    • 4xMRM10 = 8 slots ------------------------ 1xMRM40 = 7 slots
    • 4xMRM10 = 16 heat ----------------------- 1xMRM40 = 11.5 heat (this is the big one, in my opinion)
    • 4xMRM10 = 4.3 sec. cooldown ------------ 1xMRM40 = 4.75 sec. cooldown (significant, but minor)
    So here's the thing. You run 4xMRM10, and you're producing 4.5 more heat with every volley, than if you ran a single MRM40. And the only real advantage you have is the slightly lower cooldown, which is nice, but once you reach your heat-capacity, will make almost no difference, as the determining factor for your DPS in that scenario will still come down to heat efficiency, which (remember) the MRM40 still does better.

    So the takeaway, at least for this build, is that it's probably more worthwhile to take a single MRM40 and 2xMRM10, rather than 6xMRM10. Although this will affect the cooldowns, it will increase the heat efficiency of the build rather significantly. And it won't even affect the ghost-heat on an alpha, since MRM10 penalties are higher than MRM40 penalties anyway.

    In the end, I'm not criticizing the build; I just wanted to point out how inconsistent PGI has been with these weapons, and how it's actually not always better to use the smallest when possible.


    There is one obvious exception to all this, and that's where a given build lacks sufficient slots to fit an MRM40 (for example, if the MRMs are backup weapons alongside something else). In that case, MRM10s may be your only option, and it would then be advisable to equip them if it fit the intended build design.
     
    Trippton, CarloArmato and Aylek like this.
  6. The Verge

    The Verge Moderator Staff Member

    4,367
    496
    231
  7. Falconium

    Falconium Administrator Staff Member

    1,499
    470
    67
    Thing is, there alot of weapons that have similar comparisons. So maybe I will do a guide or 8 (could end up being more - I don't know), to demonstrate the various decisions one can make in choosing between weapons WITHIN a given weapon-type.
     
  8. Northstate

    Northstate New Member

    5
    0
    2
    The upside of having 4xMRM10 vs. 1xMRM40 is that you can spread out your weapon systems across multiple hardpoints, so it is not catastrophic to lose the 1 torso that matters.
     
  9. CarloArmato

    CarloArmato Professional Potato Carrier

    1,530
    464
    165
    If you lose a side torso, you also lose 4 DHS out of 10. With such a hot build, it is equal to be already dead because you will be too busy to cooldown rather to shoot.

    A dual MRM30 build looks better, but there are better MRM carrier around because this chassis has no cooldown quirks.


    In general, boating MRM10 is a bad idea, unless you REALLY need that additional ton the MRM20 and MRM30 would take away
     

Share This Page